Literature Times
No Result
View All Result
  • American Literature
    • Introduction
    • Novel
      • Introduction
      • Ernest Hemingway
      • Jazz by Toni Morrison
      • The Scarlet Letter
      • To Kill a Mockingbird
    • Plays
      • The Hairy Ape by Eugene O’Neil
      • The Crucible by Arthur Miller
    • Poetry
      • Adrienne Rich
      • Maya Angelou
      • Sylvia Plath
      • T.S. Eliot
      • Ted Hughes
    • Stories
      • The Masque of the Red Death
      • To Build a Fire
  • Pakistani Literature
    • History
    • Poetry
      • Anniversary by Daud Kamal
    • Novels
      • The Reluctant Fundamentalist
    • Short Stories
      • Toba Tek Singh
  • Postcolonial
    • Introduction
    • Concepts
    • Novels
      • Devil on the Cross
      • Things Fall Apart
  • British Literature
    • History
      • Anglo-Saxon
      • The Age of Chaucer
      • Renaissance Literature
      • Age of Shakespeare
      • The Age of Johnson
      • Elizabethan Age
      • Restoration Period
      • The Age of Milton
      • Victorian Age
    • Novels
      • D.H. Lawrence
        • Sons and Lovers
      • James Joyce
        • A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man
      • Jane Austin
        • Pride and Prejudice
      • Mary Shelley
        • Frankenstein
      • Thomas Hardy
        • The Mayor of Casterbridge
      • Virginia Woolf
        • To the Lighthouse
    • Plays
      • August Strindberg
        • Ghost Sonata
      • Christopher Marlowe
        • Doctor Faustus
      • Henrik Ibsen
        • A Doll’s House
      • John Osborne
        • Look Back in Anger
      • William Shakespeare
        • Macbeth
        • Twelfth Night
      • Samuel Beckett
        • Waiting for Godot
        • Words and Music
      • Sophocles
        • Antigone
    • Essayists
      • Jonathan Swift
        • A Modest Proposal
    • Poetry
      • John Milton
        • Paradise Lost
      • Seamus Heaney
      • W.B. Yeats
      • William Wordsworth
      • W.H. Auden
  • More
    • Basics of Literature
    • Greek Mythology
    • Linguistics
    • Literature
    • Novel
    • One Act Play
    • World Literature
      • Short Stories
        • Guy de Maupassant
        • Jorge Luis Borges
          • The Garden of Forking Paths
          • The Library of Babel
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Contact Us
Contact
  • American Literature
    • Introduction
    • Novel
      • Introduction
      • Ernest Hemingway
      • Jazz by Toni Morrison
      • The Scarlet Letter
      • To Kill a Mockingbird
    • Plays
      • The Hairy Ape by Eugene O’Neil
      • The Crucible by Arthur Miller
    • Poetry
      • Adrienne Rich
      • Maya Angelou
      • Sylvia Plath
      • T.S. Eliot
      • Ted Hughes
    • Stories
      • The Masque of the Red Death
      • To Build a Fire
  • Pakistani Literature
    • History
    • Poetry
      • Anniversary by Daud Kamal
    • Novels
      • The Reluctant Fundamentalist
    • Short Stories
      • Toba Tek Singh
  • Postcolonial
    • Introduction
    • Concepts
    • Novels
      • Devil on the Cross
      • Things Fall Apart
  • British Literature
    • History
      • Anglo-Saxon
      • The Age of Chaucer
      • Renaissance Literature
      • Age of Shakespeare
      • The Age of Johnson
      • Elizabethan Age
      • Restoration Period
      • The Age of Milton
      • Victorian Age
    • Novels
      • D.H. Lawrence
        • Sons and Lovers
      • James Joyce
        • A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man
      • Jane Austin
        • Pride and Prejudice
      • Mary Shelley
        • Frankenstein
      • Thomas Hardy
        • The Mayor of Casterbridge
      • Virginia Woolf
        • To the Lighthouse
    • Plays
      • August Strindberg
        • Ghost Sonata
      • Christopher Marlowe
        • Doctor Faustus
      • Henrik Ibsen
        • A Doll’s House
      • John Osborne
        • Look Back in Anger
      • William Shakespeare
        • Macbeth
        • Twelfth Night
      • Samuel Beckett
        • Waiting for Godot
        • Words and Music
      • Sophocles
        • Antigone
    • Essayists
      • Jonathan Swift
        • A Modest Proposal
    • Poetry
      • John Milton
        • Paradise Lost
      • Seamus Heaney
      • W.B. Yeats
      • William Wordsworth
      • W.H. Auden
  • More
    • Basics of Literature
    • Greek Mythology
    • Linguistics
    • Literature
    • Novel
    • One Act Play
    • World Literature
      • Short Stories
        • Guy de Maupassant
        • Jorge Luis Borges
          • The Garden of Forking Paths
          • The Library of Babel
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Literature Times
No Result
View All Result
Home An Apology for Poetry

For Sidney, How Poetry is Superior Over Philosophy and History?

Shaheer by Shaheer
January 3, 2022
Reading Time: 6 mins read
0
For-Sidney-How-Poetry-is-Superior-Over-Philosophy-and-History-1

Sidney has devoted plenty of space in his essay to discussing the comparative merits of poetry on one hand and philosophy and history on the other. Nevertheless, he gives poetry a place above both philosophy and history; and offers several reasons.

The first point he made, that poetry was the earliest form of composition. Poetry is venerated for its antiquity. Philosophers and historians came later than the poets. The second point was that the philosophers of an earlier time, for instance in Greece, appeared before the people in the form of poets. Third, he points to two philosophers, Empedocles and Parmenides, who wrote their natural philosophy in verse. It was historians who borrowed their style of writing from poets. Thirdly, and most importantly, all learning aims at the moral improvement of human beings.

The philosopher is likely to say that it is he who teaches human beings what virtue is. In other words, the philosopher claims to be a better teacher of virtue than anybody else. The historian will say that the philosopher teaches theoretical virtue while the historian teaches practical virtue. The philosopher teaches virtue by specific abstract considerations, while the historian teaches virtue by depicting humankind’s experiences through the ages.

Sidney points out that the philosopher and the historian have the same goal, the philosopher uses precept, and the historian uses an example. A poet performs the functions of the philosopher and historian. The poet employs both precepts and examples. The abstract statements of the philosophers are not easily understood, while the historian is tied to the particular truth of things.

Sidney begins his defense by pointing out that poetry was the earliest form of composition everywhere and that for a long time, the philosophers of ancient Greece appeared to the world in the guise of poets. At the same time, even historians readily borrowed the poetic style of writing.

Read About: What is a Short Story in English Literature?

The poet, says Sidney, imitates the “works of nature, as do other artists and men of learning. But the poet, while imitating nature, transcends it and builds a new Nature. Poetry is superior to philosophy and history so far as teaching virtue and urging human beings to live virtuously. The poet employs both the method of precept and the method of example. The philosopher abstractly conveys virtue. But the poet gives virtue by a concrete portrayal of virtuous characters. The poet is therefore superior to the philosopher. As for the historian, he does describe virtue and vice through actual historical examples; but he has to remain tied to what has happened.

Quoting Aristotle, Sidney says that poetry is more philosophical and more profound than history. Poetry is superior to philosophy because it has the power to stir or move the reader’s mind in a way philosophy cannot do. Thus, the poet wins the mind of the reader.

Then Sidney moves to elaborate on the view that poetry is an imitation. The poet, like other men learning, imitates the objects of nature. However, the poet goes beyond nature. The poet is carried forward and upward by the vigor of his invention and imagination to build up another Nature. The poet creates such new forms as the demigods, Cyclops, and Furies. The poet depicts more beautification of the world than the real one. The poet portrays human beings of the kind who never existed in nature. Nature has never created such a constant friend as Pylades, such a brave man as Orlando, such a true prince as Cyrus, so excellent a man in every way as Aeneas.

The Greeks, says Sidney, were fully justified in giving the poet the title of a “maker.” To Sidney, therefore, a maker is a creator. Indeed, the creative faculty is the highest gift with which man has been blessed; and this creative faculty is found in the poet. Thus Sidney does not regard poetic imitation as something slavish. On the contrary, the poet’s imitation of nature is not a tame copy of what is seen and found in the real world.

According to Sidney, Poetry teaches and delights; but that is not all. Sidney also points out the power of poetry to move the mind and stir the heart. It is by its ability to move the minds it influences the behavior and conduct. After reading Homer’s Odyssey, and after going through the incident of Aeneas carrying old Anchises on his back, everyone would like to perform a deed of similar virtue.

This example shows that the poet using delight as his instrument influences the readers’ minds more effectively than any other art does. As virtue is the most excellent end of all worldly learning, poetry is the most familiar way to teach virtue. Therefore, it is wrong to condemn or criticize poetry in any of its forms, says Sidney. He then defended the various forms of poetry and stated the benefits of pastoral poetry, elegiac poetry, comic and satiric poetry, tragic poetry, heroic poetry, etc. Finally, Sidney speaks of lyrical poetry:

“I never heard the old song of Percy and Douglas that I found not my heart moved more than with a trumpet.”

Sidney comes very close to Longinus’s view about the power of poetry to “transport.” In this respect, Sidney takes up a position that links him with romantic poets, though, on the whole, he is a neoclassical critic. Nevertheless, poetry was criticized by the Puritans, and Sidney needed to meet the challenge which men like Stephen Gosson were flinging at it.

Sidney regards poetry as the most fruitful form of knowledge and, therefore, as the monarch of all branches of learning. In this way, Sidney glorifies poetry and ranks it above philosophy and history and above the sciences like astronomy and geometry. He goes to the extreme when he says:

“I still and utterly deny that there is, sprung out of the earth, a more fruitful knowledge (than poetry). Therefore, it is off the mark to assert that poetry is the most profound or fertile learning cause.

Poetry has its rightful place as art that offers delight, pleasure, and moral instruction, revealing the mysteries of the human mind and human nature, which consoles in distresses and sorrows, which uplifts souls and transports into another world, and makes lives worth living. Similarly, Sidney goes off the mark when he says that an astronomer, a geometrician, or a physician may tell lies but that a poet does not tell lies. We agree that a poet does not tell lies, but we do not admit that a scientist tells lies.

Thoughts? Share in the comment section!

For free Udemy courses visit this site: Free Udemy Courses

And yes! if you need premium accounts at cheapest rate inbox me on my Facebook page at: Premium Palace

Subscribe my YouTube channel at: The Stream Post

Follow on Facebook page of Literature Times at: Literature Times on Facebook

Tags: apology for poetry philip sidneyhow does sidney establish the superiority of poetryphilip sidneyphilip sidney an apology for poetryphilip sidney apology for poetryphilip sidney criticismphilip sidney defence of poetryphilip sidney defense of poesyphilip sidney defense of poetryphilip sidney literary criticismsuperiority of poetrysuperiority of poetry over history and philosophysuperiority of poetry over history and philosophy by sidneysuperiority of poetry over philosophysuperiority of poetry over philosophy and history
ShareTweetPin
Shaheer

Shaheer

I'm a well-rounded individual who combines technical expertise with creative writing skills to provide comprehensive and compelling content to the readers. My passion for technology, literature, and writing drives them to stay up to date with the latest trends and developments in these areas.

Related Posts

Matthew Arnold’s “Culture and Anarchy”: A Comprehensive Analysis
Classical Criticism

Matthew Arnold’s “Culture and Anarchy”: A Comprehensive Analysis

August 27, 2023
Exploring Matthew Arnold's Humanism Literature as a Critique of Life
Classical Criticism

Exploring Matthew Arnold’s Humanism: Literature as a Critique of Life

August 26, 2023
Aristotles-Concept-of-Catharsis-Explained-1
Classical Criticism

Aristotle’s Concept of Catharsis Explained

January 3, 2022
Explain-the-Concept-of-Tragedy-by-Aristotle-1
Classical Criticism

Explain the Concept of Tragedy by Aristotle

January 3, 2022
Next Post
What-Were-the-Answers-of-Sidney-on-Charges-on-Poetry-1

What Were the Answers of Sidney on Charges on Poetry?

What-is-Literature-and-Virtue-in-Apology-for-Poetry-by-Sidney-1

What is Literature and Virtue in Apology for Poetry by Sidney?

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recommended Stories

John-Donne-as-a-Metaphysical-Poet-2-1

John Donne as a Metaphysical Poet

January 3, 2022
Who Were the University Wits and Their Impact on Literature

Who Were the University Wits and Their Impact on Literature?

September 20, 2024
Waiting-for-Godot-and-Language-as-a-Theme-1

Waiting for Godot and Language as a Theme

January 4, 2022

Popular Stories

  • Define Tragedy and its elements by Aristotle?

    Define Tragedy and Its Elements

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The Evolution of Feminist Literary Criticism: A Comprehensive Guide

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The Reluctant Fundamentalist Chapter 9 Summary and Analysis

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Aristotle’s Concept of Catharsis Explained

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Critical Analysis of the Poem “Partition” by W.H. Auden

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
Literature Times

Literature Times is a platform that provides literary analysis and article focused on English Literature.

LEARN MORE »

Literary Movements

  • Absurdism
  • Aestheticism
  • Existentialism
  • Expressionism
  • Formalism
  • Magical Realism
  • Marxism
  • Naturalism
  • Nihilism
  • Postmodernism
  • Surrealism

Literary Theory

  • F.R. Leavis
  • Matthew Arnold
  • Defamiliarization
  • Formalism
  • Marxism
  • Narratology
  • Post-Structuralism
  • Structuralism

Author’s Pick

  • Basics of Literature
  • Classical Criticism
  • Development of Novel
  • Essays
  • Greek Mythology
  • Moral Stories
  • Reflections

© 2025 Literature Times | Founded by Shaheer

No Result
View All Result
  • American Literature
    • Introduction
    • Novel
      • Introduction
      • Ernest Hemingway
      • Jazz by Toni Morrison
      • The Scarlet Letter
      • To Kill a Mockingbird
    • Plays
      • The Hairy Ape by Eugene O’Neil
      • The Crucible by Arthur Miller
    • Poetry
      • Adrienne Rich
      • Maya Angelou
      • Sylvia Plath
      • T.S. Eliot
      • Ted Hughes
    • Stories
      • The Masque of the Red Death
      • To Build a Fire
  • Pakistani Literature
    • History
    • Poetry
      • Anniversary by Daud Kamal
    • Novels
      • The Reluctant Fundamentalist
    • Short Stories
      • Toba Tek Singh
  • Postcolonial
    • Introduction
    • Concepts
    • Novels
      • Devil on the Cross
      • Things Fall Apart
  • British Literature
    • History
      • Anglo-Saxon
      • The Age of Chaucer
      • Renaissance Literature
      • Age of Shakespeare
      • The Age of Johnson
      • Elizabethan Age
      • Restoration Period
      • The Age of Milton
      • Victorian Age
    • Novels
      • D.H. Lawrence
      • James Joyce
      • Jane Austin
      • Mary Shelley
      • Thomas Hardy
      • Virginia Woolf
    • Plays
      • August Strindberg
      • Christopher Marlowe
      • Henrik Ibsen
      • John Osborne
      • William Shakespeare
      • Samuel Beckett
      • Sophocles
    • Essayists
      • Jonathan Swift
    • Poetry
      • John Milton
      • Seamus Heaney
      • W.B. Yeats
      • William Wordsworth
      • W.H. Auden
  • More
    • Basics of Literature
    • Greek Mythology
    • Linguistics
    • Literature
    • Novel
    • One Act Play
    • World Literature
      • Short Stories
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Contact Us

© 2025 Literature Times | Founded by Shaheer